Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cole's avatar

You might be interested in reading Aziz Rana's book on America's complicated relationship with republican notions of freedom and the various coalitions that have emerged to fight reaction and try and 'renovate' the project at various points in the country's history. I think many of the points about the odd character of American politics has faded in the last half-century. Associational life has genuinely withered and the biggest sources of divergent political outcomes here are path-dependent. Our arid political culture is more or less the arid political culture of Europe and Japan. Our class dealignment is theirs. Our economy is joined with theirs. On the flip side of things, trade liberalization and corporate consolidation, along with special arrangements like liquidity swap lines between central banks, seems to have brought the most powerful sections of the various 'national capitals' closer and closer together. I think these are all good reasons to try and develop more universal strategies, rather than lean into the better parts of Americana. But maybe you're right and we have to attend to the little differences in what is left of national culture. I'm all in favor of talking about freedom more and equality a bit less.

Expand full comment
Itsveryquiet's avatar

Man, this is good as hell, especially the third part. I’m an old unionist, but my dad and some other older guys I knew were big into the New Left and the SDS. This series has been a great examination of the critiques of that generation, and your own critiques of those critiques. I guess my own (unoriginal) criticism of the new left is that they were too suspicious of the old materialist tradition, without which tradition there’s no way forward for the Left. Thanks for writing this.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts