Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris Maisano's avatar

I have not read Moyn's book so I can't comment on it directly, but when I hear "Cold War liberal" or "Cold War liberalism" the figures who come to mind for me are not philosophers and intellectuals like Hannah Arendt or Isaiah Berlin, but Hubert Humphrey or Scoop Jackson or the later Max Shachtman - politicians, organizers, and activists who combined a hawkish, anti-communist foreign policy with an essentially social democratic domestic policy. For these figures, Cold War liberalism was very much a "fighting faith" (Arthur Schlesinger, Jr's term, I believe) that sought to build a great society (to coin a phrase) with strong labor unions, an expansive federal welfare state, etc. as an alternative to Communism. The domestic policy planks of Scoop Jackson's 1976 presidential campaign included, from an old New York Times article I dug up, "a Federal takeover of welfare costs, full national health insurance under the Kennedy‐Corman bill, an increase in Federal aid to education from 7 percent to 33 percent over three or four years, a national housing program aimed at building three million units a year, Federal insurance of municipal bonds and full employment under the Humphrey‐Hawkins bill." This is at least as ambitious, arguably even more ambitious, than what Bernie Sanders campaigned on in 2016 and 2020. So I find Moyn's apparent contention that Cold War liberalism entailed a turn *away* from grand visions and collective projects to be fairly baffling.

Expand full comment
Silke Weineck's avatar

The conflation of racism and imperialism/pro-colonialism is astoundingly common -- the two are, of course, intimately linked, and pro-colonialism needs racism -- but not vice versa. Kant was clearly a racist and just as clearly an anti-colonialist (at least in Perpetual Peace), but Germany is currently having a very stupid "was Kant a racist?" debate because nobody appears capable of grasping that you can be both a racist and think colonialism was a crime against humanity, so it's an endless cycle of "But On the Different Human Races" v "But Perpetual Peace."

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts